Friday, May 18, 2012

Gay Inc USA:
Flurry of Futile Releases on IDAHO

(Is a bomb scare the only way to get Joe Solmonese out of HRC's office in the daytime? Credit: Will O'Bryan, Metro Weekly.)

Let's have a look at how American LGBT advocacy groups large and small marked International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia yesterday, judge how engaged they were from a visibility perspective.

The the Human Rights Campaign held a forum inside their Washington headquarters titled The Road to Safety: Strengthening Protection of LGBTI Refugees in Uganda and Kenya. It was cosponsored by Human Rights First, which issued a report that day with that title, Global Equality, and the United Nations Refugee Agency.

Neither the HRC release nor the story on the meeting from Metro Weekly list an actual LGBT refugee as among the invited speakers, nor does it appear any Ugandans or Kenyans were present.

I'll give the sponsoring organizations small credit for doing something, an event very much in their comfort zone. It's too much to ask these lobbyists and nonprofit researchers to get out of the suites and into the streets, say, in front of one of the many foreign embassies within walking distance of HRC.

Sure, address the needs of LGBT refugees, but don't forget the power of also picketing at embassies of government oppressing LGBT people. 

The Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation observed IDAHO by writing a blog post, the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force's blog marked the day, while the Truth Wins Out blog commented on IDAHO actions in Italy.

New York City's Anti Violence Project sent out an email inviting everyone to attend a meeting at their office about bathroom safety issues for LGBT people. Nothing about IDAHO was posted on their site, but their Facebook page reported the meeting was their third in a series of such talks on the same issues and IDAHO is omitted from the post.

What about the International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission, also based in New York? They issued a release recognizing the day.

From the Human Rights Watch site, we learn that one of their LGBT researchers penned an essay the day before IDAHO about how a UN official's video promoting gay love and tolerance get her arrested in St. Petersburg, Russia.

Not that HRC's organizing around IDAHO is any great shakes, the flurry of releases from the others shows the low importance they give to the day of global solidarity where many risk harm and being bloodied by taking to the streets to be visible. And designating an already-schedule in-house meeting does not impress.

All these groups in New York must be allergic to the hundreds of foreign consulates, trade offices and missions to the United Nation because the professional LGBT advocates could muster up a single public protest at one anti-gay government office. 

Until I read a column at the Advocate, I had no idea the IDAHO committee had an American-based campaigns officer named Ryan Ubuntu Olson. He never reached out to us here in San Francisco, nor did he offer any assistance in attracting more folks or media to our May 17 action.

Based on the fact that he says nothing in his Advocate piece about actually staging an action himself, I can safely say he would fit right in at any of the Gay Inc groups mentioned.

If just the people at HRC making more than $100,000, or the top three employees and their executive assistants at the New York groups decided to stage a picket at an embassy or UN mission, there would be a decent crowd for the cameras and reporters to cover.

Out of the suites! Into the streets!


Anonymous said...

Michael, the sad fact is, the US does not much care about IDAHO. It's not a big deal there. Whereas in Europe and other parts of the world, where the activists and their events are younger, and their concerns more urgent, IDAHO has more resonance than Stonewall. Makes sense...
Andrea Gilbert, Athens Pride, Greece (June 9, 2012)

Mr Speaker said...

You are always sport on with the truth, while some us have always taking the risk to fight for what we believe in this professional activist and groups who sit in their armchair does nothing but still want to dictate what we can say, do or can not do. I hope they take your comment seriously and start getting out on the street to begin to do the real job of equality and human rights for all.

Anonymous said...

Gee, NGLTF marked the day on its blog? Glad we have a "task force" on hand to blog for us.

Also regarding NGLTF, it's 2011 Form 990 is now available. On Guidestar, not the TF's website, naturally.

I still can't figure out what the TF actually accomplishes.

It puts on a creating change conference year after year, but there is not a shred of evidence that the conference itself has directly or indirectly created any change. It does channel some money and staff to state and local campaigns, but the 990 clearly shows that those donations are only a small fraction of its revenue. It's like paying a dollar for a dime.

I don't know what else you can say about a group that is still working fruitlessly on items from its 1973 "to do" list.