Monday, September 10, 2012

Obama's Third Flag-Lowering 
Request Rejected by Castro Merchants

(No question: This man would honor President Obama's proclamation and 9/11 hero Mark Bingham.)

For the third time in as many months the iconic rainbow flag on city property at Harvey Milk Plaza in San Francisco, controlled by the private Merchants of Upper Market Castro, won't be lowered out of respect for a proclamation issued by President Barack Obama. Earlier today, the leader of the free world, released this decree:

NOW, THEREFORE, I, BARACK OBAMA, President of the United States of America, do hereby proclaim September 11, 2012, as Patriot Day and National Day of Service and Remembrance. I call upon all departments, agencies, and instrumentalities of the United States to display the flag of the United States at half-staff on Patriot Day and National Day of Service and Remembrance in honor of the individuals who lost their lives on September 11, 2001. I invite the Governors of the United States and the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico and interested organizations and individuals to join in this observance.

Longtime LGBT community documentarian Bill Wilson, after reading the president's words, made a written request to MUMC to lower the rainbow flag. Here's MUMC's reply from their president Terry Bennett, pictured, general manager of Cliff's Variety:

Thanks for your email, just received late morning today, the day before the effective date for your Rainbow Flag request. This does not provide sufficient time for MUMC's volunteer Board to consider the request, and so we cannot respond definitively. Please see MUMC's publicly-posted Policy regarding the Rainbow Flag at Harvey Milk Plaza, posted on our website at Please especially note portions of that Policy regarding the fundamental principle of the Flag Policy, and timing of requests.

What MUMC doesn't understand is that President Obama is not familiar with their hurdles for lowering the rainbow flag. He's kind of busy with other issues right now. Too bad MUMC does not provide for any flexibility when our president issues such proclamation. In early August, when the president and Mayor Ed Lee requested flags fly at half-staff to honor the shooting victims in the Sikh Temple killings in Wisconsin, Wilson made a request to Bennett for a flag lowering. Bennett's reply:

We're also working on clarifying the City's intent here, and on a mechanical issue with the Flag, for both of which we hope to have answers in the morning. 

Um, the mayor's intent was clear: Lower flags on city property. Bennett never stated what her mechanical excuse was. This lame rejection came a few short weeks after the bloody massacre in late July in Colorado, when MUMC again refused to lower the LGBT pride flag

The disrespecting of the LGBT community and President Obama, for a simple lowering of a rainbow flag, is a blot of shame on MUMC. They have come up with endless ridiculous reasons why they need to control this crucial piece of public property, and how burdensome it is to fly the flag at half-mast.

It would take all of ten-minutes to insert the key into the control box of the flag pole and bring down half-way. Oh, the heavy burden that requires of the stewards of the public flag at Harvey Milk Plaza!

While MUMC again shows irrational resistance to respecting the president, allowing the Castro's LGBT community to symbolically join in solidarity with other American communities tomorrow and lowering flag, they are also dishonoring local 9/11 hero Mark Bingham. He perished in the fields of Pennsylvania eleven years ago, along with thousands of other Americans and folks from foreign lands.

Thanks to Bennett, MUMC, Supervisor Scott Wiener and Mayor Ed Lee, the entire San Francisco LGBT community won't be allowed to use our public rainbow flag for a patriotic and cost-free purpose.

No comments: