Tuesday, January 15, 2008
Monday, January 14, 2008
Serosorting = Stigma or Prevention?
Agenda
January 15, 2008
Item 4. Panel Discussion: HIV-Related Public Health Campaigns, such as Serosorting: Prevention or Stigmatization 60 min.
Item 5. Presentation by Michael Petrelis regarding DPH Viagra campaign – discussion and possible action item:
Michael Petrelis said that he’s been concerned about Dr. Jeffrey Klausner with the S.F. Department of Pubic Health’s STD Control Unit for a number of years. In 1999 a public health ad regarding syphilis described people with the disease as “walking, ticking time bombs,” as dangerous things. He feels that this adds stigma to people with the disease and those who are at risk for contracting it, especially sex workers. He’s afraid that this would create barriers for people with syphilis in receiving care.
He also referred to an article printed in The Washington Monthly in 2000 in which Dr. Klausner was quoted as saying that people with HIV and AIDS need to be quarantined, that club goers need to be tested for party drugs, and that sex establishments should be closed. He points out that Dr. Klausner had supported a lawsuit against Pfizer, the manufacturer of Viagra.
Also in February 2007, the Bay Area Reporter printed an editorial in which they said that many gay activists have major issues with Dr. Klausner’s repeated attempts to stigmatize gay men for leading irresponsible sex lives. Mr. Petrelis feels that this stigmatization drives people away from health care.
He would like to see the Commission weigh in on these proposals and ads and point out that it is not good public health to convey negative messages and images for sex related diseases. He expressed his disappointment that others in the STD Control Unit, particularly LGBT people, did not attend tonight’s meeting to talk about the thinking behind the ads.
Commissioner Chung said that Dr. Klausner was invited to attend tonight’s meeting to respond, that he was unable to attend because he’s currently out of town, but he sent an email with attachments explaining his position. She added that there are things we can/cannot do within our purview: we cannot tell another person or office how perform their job, but it is our responsibility to constructively articulate our concerns.
Mr. Petrelis entertained questions from the Committee.
Mr. Brinkin suggested that the Committee either take a more in-depth look at this subject or request that the Commissioners write a letter of concern to the Health Commission about the possible effects these ad campaigns have on one of their constituent communities. Ms. Ulrich asked that the Committee focus on the issue of stigmatization rather than the scientific facts of high-risk behavior and correlations of it.
Friday, January 11, 2008
(Nikolai Alexeyev staging a protest duringRussia's recent election.)
My brave activist brother Nikolai Alexeyev sends word of a major advancement in Russia, not just for gays, which in and of itself is a major development, but a real stride forward for democracy.
To the courageous Nikolai, and all protesters detained in December, I say on behalf of the gay activist community in San Francisco, in political solidarity, we proudly salute you and your nonviolent quest for Russian democracy and full equality for LGBT people in your country.
Congratulations, to all Russian gays and pro-democracy forces on this legal victory.
Earlier prosecution department confirmed police breached Russian legislation
It became known on Friday that Moscow magistrates court # 367 judge Larisa Bogdanovich acquitted all gay activists detained on 2 December at the polling station # 165 during State Duma elections while they participated in "protest voting". An hour later after the activists were arrested homophobic Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov, who banned two Gay Prides in his city in 2006 and 2007, voted at the same polling station.
More than two dozens of Russian gay activists came to vote at the polling station, where Moscow Mayor usually casts his votes, to express their protest against the whole electoral process and homophobic position of all political parties including President Vladimir Putin’s "United Russia" for which Mr. Luzhkov was heading Moscow list.
13 activists were detained inside the polling station by special security and police. All of them, including the organizers of Moscow Pride Nikolai Alekseev, Nikolai Baev and Alexey Davydov, were brought to Tverskoi district police station where they spent seven hours and were accused of conducting a picket without notifying the Moscow authorities. According to the Russian law it is an administrative offence which carries a fine of up to 2,000 roubles (40 pounds).
Prosecution of Tverskoi district of Moscow ruled that by detaining gay activists for more than 3 hours policemen seriously breached Russian Administrative Code. All activists were released from police after the surprising appearance of prosecution department representatives.
Moscow magistrates court interrogated two police officers who allegedly took part in activists’ detaining on 2 December. According to court decision, police officers were unable to say what the detained persons did inside the polling station. They said that by arresting people they only followed the orders of the higher authorities within the police.
Court observed that activists did not have any agitation materials with them, they did not demand anything from the authorities by using placards. Court concluded that there was no picketing held in the meaning of Russian law on public meetings which means that persons detained did not conduct an illegal public gathering.
Organiser of Moscow Gay Pride and one of the initiators of homosexuals’ protest voting during Duma elections Nikolai Alekseev, who wrote on his ballot paper in Russian "No to homophobes! No to Luzhkov!" said on Friday that "this is our first considerable victory in courts in the legal fight with Moscow authorities and Moscow Mayor personally. Lawlessness of the authorities can be witnessed during all our actions but up to now we never won in court. This is a positive signal".
Now acquitted Russian activists are considering legal suit for moral damages against Moscow police for illegal arrest and detention.
President Putin’s "United Russia" party overwhelmingly won parliamentary elections on 2 Dece mber though the Moscow list of the party with Mr. Luzhkov as its head got slightly less votes than in the country in general.
HRC's Solmonese Spin Doctoring His NH Absence

THE WHOLE WORLD — or at least the political world — has been focused on two states for the past few weeks: Iowa and New Hampshire. Every four years, these states find themselves at the epicenter of our democratic process. At the Human Rights Campaign, we knew this day was going to come and we’ve been preparing for it.Why is it important for the GLBT community, and more specifically the Human Rights Campaign, to be playing such an active role in these states — especially when we haven’t endorsed any of the presidential contenders? [...]Our community has already had success in 2008. But this is only the beginning. As our nation continues to hold elections to determine who the party’s nominees will be, HRC will continue making sure our community, and our issues, are actively discussed and debated.
Thursday, January 10, 2008
2008 = Life or Death for Gays
(HRC's NH field organizer, Heather Gibson, on the left, and Elizabeth Birch, former leader of HRC, on the right.)"[Former HRC president Elizabeth] Birch explained her advocacy for Clinton as a 'life and death' issue."'At this moment of history for us it’s life and death. For other people it’s a wonderful privilege but for us it’s literally our lives,' said Birch, who points to the need for LGBT people to effectively care for their partners and children, the ongoing scourge of HIV/AIDS among gay men and the need for more research into the unique health issues that face lesbians."And there are still no protections for LGBT people at the federal level, Birch pointed out."Then somewhat ironically, Birch, whose HRC tenure spanned the Bill Clinton years, added, that, 'You’ll hear Clinton people try to say, ’Oh, we made such advances.’ We made no advances. We got left with ’Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,’ and the Defense of Marriage Act."So were there reasons for that? Yes. However, there’s cleanup to do now and we have to move forward and get laws in place."
[UPDATE]
Michael,Liz Birch certainly exaggerates.We made important advances under Clinton.We got for the first time executive orders protecting executive branch employees from sexual orientation discrimination.We got a total revamping of the security clearance process that ended the "special procedures" under which gay people were frequently delayed or denied on security clearances, a real problem for people in technology occupations working for government contractors.We got the first openly gay federal judge, the first openly gay ambassador, the first openly gay people occupying positions requiring Senate confirmation (like Roberta Achtenberg), the first openly gay people in senior White House staff positions.We got a major advance on asylum policy when Janet Reno adopted as official precedent a decision that gays are a "distinct social group" for purposes of analyzing eligibility for political asylum in the US for people from oppressive countries.And we got the first president who did not spout reflexively anti-gay positions from the White House on every issue.What we didn't get, unfortunately, was good pro-gay legislation, and the fault was largely because the Republican Party controlled both houses of Congress for 6 out of the 8 years of the Clinton Administration.I agree that DADT on the military was a disaster, and that the Defense of Marriage Act represented shameless political calculation by Clinton in his 1996 re-election campaign.He calculated, probably correctly, that the only way to take same-sex marriage off the table as a campaign issue (and to avoid a federal constitutional amendment writing a ban on same-sex marriage into the constitution) was to agree to DOMA, which was originally proposed, I believe, by Bob Dole.We need to remember that DOMA was passed by a Congress controlled by the Republican Party, not the Democrats (although it is surely true that Democrats, if united against it, could have filibustered it in the Senate).We need to think contextually about this and about DADT. I fault Clinton for failing to provide the leadership he should have provided back in 1993 when the military issue exploded. The best explanation is that he was confronted by leading Democrats, especially in the Senate, who told him that letting gays serve openly would not fly politically in Congress.Anyone who says we got NOTHING from the Clinton years and were set backwards is oversimplifying and misrepresenting the state of affairs. It is a mixed picture overall, and we made real progress, mainly on fronts that could be controlled solely by the executive branch due to the lack of control by Democrats of the legislative branch.We also, importantly, got our first major Supreme Court victory, Romer v. Evans, which was at least party attributable to Clinton's two Supreme Court appointments, Breyer and Ginsburg, both of whom have been pretty stalwart in supporting gay rights on the Court. (They both voted our way in Lawrence v. Texas, and they both dissented in the Boy Scouts case.) Indeed, all of GW Bush's Supreme Court appointees are firm opponents of gay rights.
From the HPPC agenda:
4. HPPC Co-Chairs/Director’s Update (Information item)
Objective: To inform HPPC members of the activities of the HPPC Co-Chairs, the Steering Committee, and the HIV Prevention Section. Dr. Grant Colfax, Director of the HIV prevention Section will give an overview of his work and the work of the HIV Prevention Section. The Co-chairs will inform HPPC members of the 2008 vision for HIV prevention planning and how the Council will support it through committee and Council work.
Tuesday, January 08, 2008
Eric references in his report an audio of the zap with Huckabee, which artist and political activist Clinton Fein has kindly posted on this Annoy.com web site. You can also contact Eric via email: esawyer (at) igc.org
And thank you, Eric, and all the other gay and AIDS activists on the NH campaign trail, bringing visibility to our issues.
^
Michael-
ACT UP, Housing Works, HealthGAP, The Student Global AIDS Campaign and the new Private Health Insurance Must Go Coalition had a few dozen activist in New Hampshire for the weekend birddogging, lobbying, disrupting and schmoozing with the candidates. We succeeded in interfacing with almost all the major candidates and positioned ourselves into being many of the first citizens called by the candidates in major Town Hall question and answer periods.
We were 2 of 4 questions at the Edwards Sat. afternoon town hall; the first and third questions and the second to the last question in Hillary's Sunday afternoon town hall meetings; we zapped Huckabee, McCain, and Guiliani twice.
So where were HRC, NGLTF, AIDS Action and GMHC - missing. Most of our folks were activists and volunteers and not staff - except a few from Housing Works and HealthGAP.
I am forwarding a report and transcript. - Eric Sawyer
ACT UP founding member Eric Sawyer confronted former Governor Mike Huckabee at a supporter’s reception after the Sunday night debate in New Hampshire.As Huckabee took the podium to speak to supporters a, a dozen dozen AIDS activists started clanking their glasses calling out "Toast, toast!"Sawyer called out “Governor Huckabee may I offer a toast?”Huckabee: “Why not!”Sawyer : “As a Christian whose faith is very important to me - I want to toast to Mike Huckabee – the only politician with the courage to stand up for Christian values!”
Sawyer toasts to the crowd's applause.(Attached recording starts here with crowd applause.)Sawyer continued: “ I’m a Methodist like you and my values and my faith are very important to me - I know you are a Baptist..."
Crowd laughter…Huckabee breaks in: “I was going to say, you are - you know, a Methodist is a waterless Baptist, you know that!”Sawyer: “That’s, that’s true, and ah, I don’t know that my Preacher would agree with that – but ah – I also wanted to say that one thing – I think one of the Christian values that is really important is that God embraced everyone and that Jesus Christ embraced everyone, including lepers. And it hurts me as a person of faith - who is one of your supporters because of the fact that years ago you said that people like me, people with AIDS should be quarantined and if I was quarantined I could not vote for you."Huckabee interrupts: "Thank you for coming tonight."Sawyer concludes: "And I, I hope you; I hope you will revisit that statement.Huckabee say: "Thank you for coming, thank you for coming."Crowd noise rises.Activists chant, and chant, and chant: "People With AIDS are dying, and you're not even trying. AIDS treatments now!"Huckabee again: "Thank you for coming. Excuse me. Thank you for coming. Thank you for coming, let's be seated. Excuse me ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for coming tonight. The great thing is that in a free country, everybody has a chance to speak-– not everybody has to agree with us. Thank you very much for coming."A Huckabee supporter yells out: "Ok, wear a rubber."
Union Leader: Bill Clinton Blames
Primary Calendar for Obama Surge
I know the Clintons are desperate to salvage Hillary hugely faltering effort for a third term in the White House, but is it wise of the former president to blame his wife's looming big loss today on the primary calendar?
What I detect in Bill's thinking here is an insult New Hampshire voters, and that after much exposure to Hillary and her campaign, voters are not flocking to Sen. Barack Obama because they like him and his positions, they're doing so because of favorable press coverage of him since he won Iowa. Bill's really going out of his way to denigrate the intelligence of voters.
It doesn't appear as though Bill believes New Hampshire voters are smart enough to make up their minds about who to vote for unless they have plenty of time between the first caucus and primary.
I think what he's really saying is that the Clinton campaign needed more time to go negative on their chief opponent and the condensed primary calendar just did not give them that opportunity.
Could the real problem for the Clintons be their operatives and campaign simply were woefully unprepared for a very competitive election and they're blaming voters (!) for rejecting Hillary? Twisted logic to be sure, but that is the Clintons' way of doing things.
Hey Bill, here's a radical notion you should start to cotton to: No third Clinton term.
Last point: I'm not convinced the Obama momentum between Iowa and New Hampshire would necessarily have been broken by a longer stretch between the voting in those states, even if the Clintons had had the time to slime him.
CLAREMONT – Former President Bill Clinton said the timing of the New Hampshire primary is to blame if his wife, New York Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton, doesn't beat Illinois Senator Barack Obama in their quest for the Democratic presidential nomination.
Asked by a voter in Claremont how the Clinton camp planned to propel itself past Obama, Clinton said, "The answer is there might not be enough time, because New Hampshire made a decision that I didn't agree with."
He said the state gave up much of its political sway by holding its primary so close to last Thursday's Iowa caucus. With more time, he said, more voters would begin to question the substance behind the Obama campaign.
"The point is the momentum is broken when people get to think for themselves and not get caught up in the press hysteria," he said. [...]
Monday, January 07, 2008
Avoiding New Hampshire
(Who else was at the party with Solmonese? None other than clueless Paris Hilton! Both photos taken by Alex Berliner.)For two days, I have been tromping through the New Hampshire snow for Hillary Clinton. Door to door, even farm to farm, the goal is to get people in their homes to engage in a discussion. The entire team for the Franklin and the South Lakes Region is lesbian and gay. We have swept the area and the local organizers are very impressed. [...]My experiences have varied, but none compared to one encounter yesterday. A couple of us were precinct-walking in a trailer park in Franklin, New Hampshire. The tired, circa 1970 mobile homes looked as though they had been tossed there at some point, and were laying fallow. But inside was life—real families, real problems.
I came upon one mobile home with a sign outside that read: "Fuck With Me, And You Fuck With the Whole Trailer Park." Based on my low brow upbringing and feeling that the Democratic party should go anywhere to take back our country, I plowed ahead up the three metal steps to the door. [...]As we left he said, "You know, you are the only people from any of the campaigns to ever visit my home. That gets in your head. You think about it. That will stay with me. Who knows who I'll vote for..."
One more for Hillary. Maybe.


