Saturday, January 05, 2008

Human Rights Campaign MIA in New Hampshire
-[Update at the end with info on where HRC's ED was this weekend.]-

It's been an eternity since the Iowa caucuses ended and the political world shifted attention to the primary in New Hampshire. Okay, two days isn't really that long in the real world, but in the race for president two days equals a zillion news cycles.
Not that the HRC reports from Iowa were anything more than gushing messages from star-struck volunteers about their goofy escapades trying to get political idols to sign t-shirts, but at least those reports gave us a small indication of HRC's participation in Iowa.
The lack of HRC blog entries or news releases from New Hampshire really isn't all that great a loss for political junkies, but it does raise a few questions about what exactly is the nation's largest gay political group doing on the campaign trail to promote our issues.
While the fanzine quality of HRC blog entries from Iowa certainly lacked depth and seriousness, I'm sorry to see they have not continued from the next state on the primary calendar.
I have a few hard questions for HRC about their involvement with the race in New Hampshire:
1. Has HRC done any polling of gay voters in NH? If they have, where are the results, and if HRC hasn't polled, why not?
2. Is HRC coordinating volunteer efforts with any of the candidates up there?
3. Will HRC be running any NH-based TV or radio spots, or ads in the newspapers and on blogs, promoting gay issues?
4. Are any top HRC leaders or board members engaged in any significant way with any candidates efforts in NH?
5. What is the budget for HRC's NH operations leading up to Tuesday's vote?
6. Is HRC engaged in or supporting general get-out-the-vote activities in NH?
What does it say about HRC, and it's alleged 600,000-plus members, that two days after Iowa declared Barack Obama and Mike Huckabee the winners, the group has said nothing from New Hampshire about how's its engaged in that state?
If the party girl and boy attitude of HRC from Iowa and their silence so far from New Hampshire are any indication of how HRC will be pushing gay concerns in the 2008 race for the White House, I'm afraid we're in for a long year of lazy advocacy from the group.
Read about our work for equality in Iowa and New Hampshire on HRC’s blog, HRC Back Story.
I guess that work is taking a break this important weekend.

UPDATE, January 6:

I am a gay man who supported an ENDA bill that included my transgender brothers and sisters, and thought the Human Rights Campaign threw them under the bus as the bill worked its way through Congress in the fall, so count me among those who believe much of the tranny anger directed at HRC and its leadership is well-deserved and spot-on.
And I fully endorse tranny leaders holding many meetings with HRC directors, but reading a report from a meeting held this weekend in San Francisco between those leaders and the head of HRC, Joe Solmonese, brought forth a few head-scratching questions to consider related to tranny and HRC leadership.
First, why, on this, the weekend leading up to the ever-increasingly important presidential primary in New Hampshire, is Solmonese on the other side of the continent? Was there really no other weekend for Solmonese to dialogue with San Francisco/Bay Area trannies?
Not that HRC asked my opinion, but I think the head of America's largest political advocacy should be promoting gay equality before the Democratic and GOP candidates for the White House up in the Granite State, not to mention pushing our gay agenda with the state's voters and the thousands of political operatives and media representatives covering the primary.

If Solmonese and HRC can't adequately engage NH voters, candidates and hordes of reporters up there, can they at least update their blog about gay-related aspects other people are doing there this weekend?
Second, if HRC is in the midst of a (public) discussion with trannies about ENDA and how the organization will work them in the future, where was the transparency for this meeting before it happened?
There were no announcements in the local gay or mainstream press about the meeting, no invitations posted on San Francisco's many gay political blog or HRC's own site.
Both the tranny leaders and the HRC executives who put on and attended this meeting should have thought about providing transparency to the proceedings. If it's one thing the gay community doesn't need from HRC, it is continued closed-door, invitation only discussions about our collective agenda.

Notes from the Trans Leadership meeting with HRC Joe Joe Solmonese 1/5/08 San Francisco

(I wrote this yesterday, as a letter to my ftm group)

I am just returned from the meeting the HRC called with San Francisco trans community leaders. I am very grateful to Cecelia Chung of the Transgender Law Center for bringing me in. Yea for south bay representation. :-) (I feel like I say that a lot in all of my
communities ;-) )

There were about 50 San Francisco area transgender leaders present, in addition to a few people from HRC. [...]
Initially, Joe spoke. Joe started off with a two pronged apology, one part being about poor communication at the height of the ENDA strategy conversion, and the other part about acknowledging they caused a lot of pain by the course they chose. He then spent some time explaining the legislative process in DC.

He also said that he did not expect to change any minds by the discussion today, though discussion was important; he knew that actions had gotten the community into the state it is in, and it will be actions that will get it out. [...]
I am not terribly optimistic that Joe took anything new 'in' at this meeting. I do believe he and the HRC are doing what they understand to be best.

Throughout the entire thing, Joe was very noncommittal, unlikely to answer things directly, entirely lacking in passion. I will say however that his very polished presentation is no doubt precisely what is needed on capitol hill. However, it's pretty terrible when speaking within the community. The lobbyist was a lot more 'real' feeling. [...]

Thursday, January 03, 2008


Guardian UK: NY Times,
Kristol's Donations & Ethical Journalism

Nice of Dan Kennedy at the Guardian in London to pick up on ethical questions I raised recently surrounding the New York Times hiring Bill Kristol and his political donations, and for placing those questions in larger context.

From yesterday's Guardian:

Left-leaning bloggers are in an uproar over the neoconservative William Kristol's landing a plum spot on the New York Times op-ed page. It's not hard to understand why. What concerns me, though, is not so much Kristol's ideology as it is that the Times has compromised its own ethics. [...]

Kristol will write his New York Times column for just a year, producing a weekly commentary that will debut on January 7. [...] But Kristol has never shown much, if any, regard for the ethical conventions of journalism, as he has remained directly involved in Republican politics.

For instance, the indefatigable blogger Michael Petrelis reports that Kristol has been a frequent financial contributor over the years to the likes of former senators George "Macaca" Allen and Spencer Abraham. I cross-checked Petrelis' digging at OpenSecrets.org and found the same contributions, as well as a slew of others made by Kristol's wife, Susan Kristol. Such donations are a serious ethical breach for any journalist. Perhaps the New York Times will make him stop, but he should have stopped on his own in the mid-1990s, when he embarked on his journalistic career. [...]

The New York Times' 54-page code of ethics forbids even clerks and secretaries from engaging in "any ... form of political partisanship while on the job." In more than a decade as a journalist, Kristol has never shown any such compunction. Can he change during his year at the New York Times? For that matter, does anyone even expect him to? We'll see.

Sure, it's great of a major publication in the United Kingdom write about Kristol's political donations and how the New York Times should address the contributions against its ethical journalism rules, but where are the columns or blog entries of professional American media watchdogs about his donations?

And the Times should quickly tell readers if Kristol will adhere to the paper's ban on political donations during his one-year gig. In my view, this is a simple matter that the public editor ought to address, along with the myriad other ethical questions raised related to the paper hiring Kristol.

Wednesday, January 02, 2008


Iran Hangs Raheleh Zamani,
27-Year-Old Mother of Two


There is tragic news today from Persian-American human rights advocate Lily Mazahery about Iran executing Raheleh Zamani this morning in Tehran. As a gay man very opposed to the death penalty in all cases and by all governments, I feel it's important to call attention to the latest executions in Iran, when Iranian are hanged or stoned to death, regardless of their sexual orientation.
I hope 2008 is a year in which effective international campaigns are mounted to end state-sanctioned killings in Iran, and in my country, the United States of America.
Here are the two messages from Lily about Raheleh Zamani case and death.
First message:

According to reliable sources, Raheleh Zamani was transferred to solitary confinement today in Tehran's Evin prison, and she is to be executed by hanging at dawn on Wednesday, January 2, 2008.

Raheleh, who is in prison for killing her husband, was originally scheduled to be executed on December 19, 2007. However, human rights lawyers and activists in Iran and abroad joined forces, once again, and caused Iran's head of judiciary, Ayatollah Shahroudi, to grant a temporary stay of execution only hours before the execution was to be carried out.

The order was designed to provide additional time for Raheleh to obtain the pardon of her in-laws, which is legally required to save her life.

The SaveDelara Campaign and the Legal Rights Institute strongy condemn Raheleh Zamani's death sentence, and urge concerned parties to take IMMEDIATE action to stop Raheleh's execution.

What You Can Do:

Contact human rights groups and activists, world organizations, and government officials to express your objection to Raheleh's upcoming execution.

Second message:

It is with profound sadness that we report the following: Raheleh Zamani was executed today at dawn, Tehran time. She was hanged in Tehran's notorious Evin prison along with 11 others as snow fell silently all around ... frozen tears of crystalized anguish for the senseless murder of a 27 year old mother of two young children.

Raheleh, a woman suffering from battered wife syndrome, betrayed by her husband and her family, and, ultimately, by a legal system that should have attended to her medical needs instead of resorting to a brutal execution, is now at rest.

Raheleh, who came from a simple and uneducated family from a small village in Iran, was married off when she was only 15 years old. She endured years of abuse at the hands of her husband, and at the end, her in-laws watched the grim proceedings as she was hanged along with eleven others.

There are no words to adequately describe the grief we all feel.

Our sincere and heartfelt thanks goes to each person who reached out to help Raheleh with letters and petitions.

May this be a reminder that these cases are indeed in need of our intervention. Hopefully, we can gather more support for those whose cases are still classified as urgent to avert a repetition of this horrific and tragic ending to a precious life.

May she now rest in eternal peace.

Monday, December 31, 2007

How High is the San Francisco
Zoo Director's Salary?
A lot higher than the wall for the tiger yard, that's for sure.
I didn't recall seeing any mention of Manual Mollinedo's annual pay as director of the San Francisco Zoo in any of the many stories about a tiger killing a teenage boy on Christmas Day and the animal fatally shot, so I decided today to read the zoo's latest IRS 990 tax filing to find out what he earned last year.
Mollinedo's compensation was $314,038, the zoo contributed $15,702 to his benefits plan, and he received $9,548 for expenses. (For an executive making way more than a quarter million, I think he could easily take care of whatever his work-related expenses were in 2006, but I digress.)
Total package for Mollinedo came to $339,288.
Nice pocket change, wouldn't you say? No other executive at the zoo comes near to that high level of pay. The closest salary to Mollinedo's is $145,762 and that's for the director of development. I'd sure like to hear an argument from the board of directors why the boss earn a lot more than double what anyone else earns at the zoo.
For what the zoo is paying its chief, I think the city of San Francisco should have someone in charge of the zoo who will make damn sure the animals are well cared for, can't escape captivity, and that high walls to contain tigers are in place.
Even if the tragedy of last week had not occurred, I'd still say the zoo chief's salary is excessive and may be unjustified, because the non-profit zoo's revenue for 2006 was nearly $22.4 million and it seems way out of line for a non-profit group with that sized budget to pay the head honcho more than a quarter million dollars.

Read the zoo's latest IRS 990 here.

(The Chorus at City Hall. Sorry, I couldn't locate a photo of them at the Castro!)

SF Gay Chorus Sings Solidarity
for Russians, Eastern Europeans


My boyfriend and I attended one of the Christmas concerts at the Castro Theatre put on by the San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus last week. It was my first time at this annual holiday musical treat and I thoroughly enjoyed the choice of songs and beautiful men's voices, along with being with my wonderful partner and our large extended gay family in the historic theatre for part of the holiday season.
After the show, we read the program from the chorus and were pleased to see this in the welcome note from Kathleen McGuire, the artistic director and conductor:
"Sergei Rachmaninoff's beloved 'Vespers' has become a symbolic piece for Russians, especially since, soon after its composition in 1915, the Soviet Union banned all religious music. It has been said that no composition represents the end of an era so clearly as this liturgical work. In 2005, an Orthodox priest in Russia held a private 'marriage' service for two men. When the religious authorities learned about it, they defrocked the priest and bulldozed the chapel.
"Recent pro-gay riots in Moscow led to the intimidation and incarceration of organizers and marchers. We sing from 'Vespers' tonight as a show of solidarity with our LGBT brothers and sisters in Eastern Europe."
Yes, this city is one place where we always remember gay people around the globe who struggle daily for acceptance and equality and we find creative ways to make sure foreign gays are not forgotten. I am proud of the San Francisco Gay Men's Chorus for raising their voices in solidarity with our brothers and sisters in Russia and throughout Eastern Europe.
Many thanks to the chorus members, the group's executive director, Teddy Witherington, and the artistic director for their act of choral and political solidarity.
May 2008 bring increase respect for the human rights of gays everywhere and more global solidarity and activism across all borders!
(Montage of images from the 2007 attempt at staging a gay pride event in Moscow.)

Sunday, December 30, 2007


NY Times Omits Bill Kristol's
$8,000 in GOP Donations


The Gray Lady announced over the weekend that William Kristol has been added to the paper's roster of Op Ed page columnists. Here's some minimal background from the Times' announcement on his political activities and journalistic endeavors:

He is editor and co-founder of The Weekly Standard, an influential conservative political magazine, and appears regularly on Fox News Sunday and the Fox News Channel. He was a columnist for Time magazine until that relationship was severed this month.

Mr. Kristol, 55, has been a fierce critic of The Times. In 2006, he said that the government should consider prosecuting The Times for disclosing a secret government program to track international banking transactions.

In a 2003 column on the turmoil within The Times that led to the downfall of the top two editors, he wrote that it was not “a first-rate newspaper of record,” adding, “The Times is irredeemable.”

In the mid-1990s, Mr. Kristol led the Project for the Republican Future, an influential policy study group. Before that, he was chief of staff to Vice President Dan Quayle.

That limited effort at disclosure and transparency is all fine and good, on the surface, but one thing that troubles me is what the Times omitted -- Kristol's political donations. A search of Federal Election Commission records shows Kristol has given $8,000 since 1993, all of it to GOP candidates and an anti-abortion 501(c)(4) organization.

From NewsMeat.com files:
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
WEEKLY STANDARD/EDITOR
ALLEN, GEORGE (R) Senate - VA
FRIENDS OF GEORGE ALLEN
$250,
general 07/10/06
Mr. William Kristol
COLE, TOM (R) House (OK 04)
COLE FOR CONGRESS
$1,000,
primary 08/05/02
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
NEWS CORPORATION
ABRAHAM, SPENCER SENATOR (R) Senate - MI
ABRAHAM SENATE 2000
$1,000,
primary 12/23/98
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
NEWS CORPORATION
ABRAHAM, SPENCER SENATOR (R) Senate - MI
ABRAHAM SENATE 2000
$1,000,
general 12/23/98
KRISTOL, BILL
WEEKLY STANDARD
SUSAN B. ANTHONY LIST INC. CANDIDATE FUND
$500
, primary 02/23/98
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
MILLER, JAMES CLIFFORD III (R) Senate - VA
MILLER FOR SENATE (1996)
$500,
primary06/06/96
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
WATTS, JULIUS CEASER JR (JC) (R) House (OK 04)
WATTS FOR CONGRESS (1994)
$250,
primary 01/17/95
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
MC LEAN, VA 22101
PROJECT FOR A REPUBLICAN
VIGILANTE, KEVIN (R) House (RI 01)
KEVIN VIGILANTE FOR CONGRESS
$250,
general 09/30/94
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
PROJECT FOR REP'LICAN FUT
LONGLEY, JAMES B JR (R) House (ME 01)
LONGLEY FOR CONGRESS '96
$500,
general 09/30/94
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
PROJECT FOR REPUBLICAN FUTURE
MCINTOSH, DAVID MARTIN (R) House (IN 02)
DAVID MCINTOSH FOR CONGRESS
$750,
general 09/30/94
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
PROJECT FOR REP'LICAN FUTURE
LONGLEY, JAMES B JR (R) House (ME 01)
LONGLEY FOR CONGRESS '96
$250,
general 08/15/94
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
PROJECT FOR THE REPUBLICAN FUTURE
ABRAHAM, SPENCER SENATOR (R) Senate - MI
ABRAHAM FOR SENATE (1994)
$1,000,
general 08/12/94
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
PROJECT FOR REPUBLICAN FUTURE
MCINTOSH, DAVID MARTIN (R) House (IN 02)
DAVID MCINTOSH FOR CONGRESS
$250
, general 06/23/94
KRISTOL, WILLIAM
BRADLEY PROJECT
ABRAHAM, SPENCER SENATOR (R) Senate - MI
ABRAHAM FOR SENATE (1994)
$1,000,
primary 06/26/93
I believe the Times had a responsibility to inform readers about Kristol's political donations and provide us with a very full picture of his thinking and electoral agenda, a responsibility the paper should have expended more energy and space on in announcing his one-year guest columnist gig.
It's not just that Kristol has made the donations, which are in line with his writing and philosophy, that are of concern to me as a Times reader, but I'm wondering if the Times has reminded Kristol of the paper's policy of prohibiting such donations by staffers and if he will adhere to this important rule from the Times' ethical guidelines:
Staff members may not themselves give money to any political candidate or election cause or raise money for one. Given the ease of Internet access to public records of campaign contributions, any political giving by a staff member would risk feeding a false impression that we are taking sides.

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

SF Weekly: Sour Prez of Milk
Club Starts Vanity AIDS Democratic Club

Nearly two weeks ago, I blogged on this development, and both SF gay newspapers, the BAR and the Bay Times, chose to ignore the Milk Club president forming a vanity Democratic club.
The latest issue of the alternative SF Weekly today runs a story about his new club, which as far as I can tell, has only one member and hasn't bothered with a single public meeting.
From the Weekly article:
Why is the head of San Francisco's most venerable gay Democratic club starting another political organization? That's what some in the gay community are asking after Brian Basinger, president of the Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club, recently launched the tentatively named HIV Democratic Club.

Well, if you think it has something to do with the big brouhaha in the Milk Club over its controversial decision to endorse incumbent state Senator Carole Migden (a lesbian) over challenger Assemblyman Mark Leno (a gay man), you're not alone. [...]

Basinger got in hot water with other Milk Club leaders after telling the Bay Area Reporter last month that an October vote pushed through by Migden supporters to endorse early in the District 3 Senate race was improper. The executive board responded by taking the highly unusual step of censuring Basinger and issuing a public letter reprimanding him for "undermining" its credibility. [...]

Basinger, executive director of the AIDS Housing Alliance, says he began talking about starting an AIDS-focused Democratic club a year ago, before the Migden-Leno race heated up. [...]

And, well, he says, the Milk Club can be "a toxic place" that isn't always welcoming for newcomers. The new organization, he sniffs, won't have 30 years of political baggage to weigh it down. Basinger says his HIV/AIDS club "will be able to work with everybody."

Hmmm, perhaps everybody except the Milk Club.

UK Home Office:
Search for Gay Asylum Stats Exceeds £600
[The following letter was sent today to the campaign people and reporters at the Freedom of Information desk at The Guardian newspaper.]
Dear Friends,
I am a San Francisco-based gay human rights advocate who is trying to pry loose data from the Foreign Office about over all gay-specific asylum claims and those made by gays from Iran, versus claims from non-gay asylum seekers.
Last week I received a reply from the Freedom of Information Team at the Foreign Office, explaining that my request exceeded the £600 cost limit. With many caveats and a degree of discouragement, the FOI Team says I can refine my request, but they are not certain doing so would produce the answers I am seeking, and under the cost limit.
Before I proceed further, I would like advice from your organization about proceeding with more manageable and smaller requests, or an appeal.
Frankly, I believe the Foreign Office should already be keeping statistics related to reasons why asylum is asked for, especially when based on sexual orientation, and the resolution of claims based on homosexual persecution or torture in one's native land.
Does your organization believe the financial burdens cited by the Foreign Office are legitimate? How would you recommend I work with the FOI Team to persuade them to search for the records I want, and then produce them, without charging a large sum of money?
Furthermore, I see The Guardian recently ran a story about FOI requests declining by 8% this year over the same time period last year. Needless to say, I am doing my part to use the FOI law to bring more transparency to the business of the UK government, particularly as it deals with gay asylum requesters.
Any guidance you can share with me would be greatly appreciated.
Sincerely yours,
Michael Petrelis

Copy of the letter from the Home Office's FOI Team:

Dear Mr Petrelis,


Thank you for your email dated 3/12/07 where you have requested information on specific reasons for claiming asylum and their outcomes. This falls to be dealt with under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. I have listed your questions below for reference [in italics].


How many cases based on claims on the grounds of sexual orientation and transgender status, have been made, from all countries? How many of those claims were successful in obtaining asylum and how many failed?


Also, since I wish to compare the success and failure rates of gay-specific claims with the overall rate of claims made for non-gay reasons, please provide me with the success and failure statistics for all other asylum claims made with the BIA.


I am very interested in learning specific information on claims made by GLBT persons from Iran. How many claims from Iranian GLBT persons were made, the number granted asylum status, the number that have been refused, the number that later succeeded on appeal?


Furthermore, if the BIA has deported GLBT people back to Iran, individuals whose claims were based on sexual orientation or transgender status, how many were deported, and how many returned voluntarily?


Please also give me comparable figures for all other non-gay claimants from Iran; how many filed, success and failure rates, how many deported.


I also request statistics for all claimants from all countries who put in a claim based on sexual orientation or transgender status. How many claims made, success and failure rates, number of GLBT deported?


Please release to me the figures for all asylum claimants on all grounds over the same period for the purpose of comparison.


How many general non-GLBT claims accepted, how many outstanding claims, how many refused, how many awaiting removal, how many formally deported, how many returned voluntarily?


Unfortunately, I am not able to provide you with the information you have requested because the information is not centrally recorded. Whilst the number of claims and their outcomes are centrally recorded and published on the Research and Development Statistical Website (RDS), personal information and the reasons cited for claiming asylum are not. This information would be held on the person’s personal file.


Therefore, in order to answer your request it would be necessary to examine manually all asylum files to retrieve the information, which due to the numbers involved is not possible.


Additionally, as part of the Home Office, the Border and Immigration Agency is not obliged under section 12 of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 to comply with any information request where the estimated costs involved in supplying the information exceed the £600 cost limit.


I regret that we cannot supply you with the information that you have asked for, as to comply with your request would exceed this cost limit. This limit applies to all central Government Departments and is based on work being carried out by one member of staff at a rate of £25 per hour, which equates to 3½ days work per request.


The costs involved include locating and retrieving information you requested, and preparing our response to you. They do not include considering whether any information is exempt from disclosure, overheads such as heating or lighting, or disbursements such as photocopying or postage.


Your request would at present be too costly to answer. This is due to the fact that the data to these questions would be held on individual case files and is not held separately.


However, if you were to refine your request further so that it falls under the £600 cost limit, we will be pleased to consider it further. Although, on this occasion I am unable to suggest how you could refine your request.


Should you wish to refine your request, so that we can provide you with answers to your questions within the £600 cost limit, please write back to me at the above address.


I should also point out that if you were to break your original request down into a series of smaller applications, we might, depending on the circumstances of the case, decline to answer if the aggregated cost of complying would exceed £600.


You should also bear in mind that even if any new request were to fall below the £600 cost limit, some information which we hold on this matter which you have requested may fall to be withheld under the terms of a number of the substantive exemptions contained in Part II of the Freedom of Information Act 2000.


These exemptions could also make it necessary for us to extend the period for responding beyond the usual 20 working day target if they involve having to consider the public interest balancing test.


If you are dissatisfied with this response, you may request an independent internal review of our handling of your request by submitting your complaint to:


Border and Immigration Agency Customer Focus Team

11th Floor, West Wing, Block 'C'

Whitgift Centre

Wellesley Road

Croydon CR9 1AT


During the independent review the department’s handling of your information request will be reassessed by staff who were not involved in providing you with this response. Should you remain dissatisfied after this internal review, you will have a right of complaint to the Information Commissioner as established by section 50 of the Freedom of Information Act.


Yours faithfully,

Mr Feakins,

Freedom of Information Team,

Resource Management Directorate

Saturday, December 15, 2007

SF Daily:
No Charges in Gay Abuse Case
A front-page story ran yesterday in the SF Daily paper about the district attorney declining to bring charges in a gay domestic violence case, but because the newspaper posts no content on its web site, the story is not available online.
Nevertheless, key excerpts from the article are shared here.
Comments and rebuttals from the perpetrator, Julius Turman, have not been omitted by me.

Unfortunately, the SF Daily reporter didn't include any response or quote from Turman, which I believe should have been integral to the story, as balanced journalism demands. Heck, there wasn't anything in the article indicating the paper had even tried to reach Turman.
Needless to say, I hope Turman is soon given the opportunity in other news accounts to present his side of things, and that a debate ensues in the gay community about the DA's handling of this case and other crimes where gays are the victim.
San Francisco Daily
December 14, 2007
No Charges in Gay Abuse Case
by Richard Cole
A man who was choked and beaten bloody in a domestic violence incident is accusing District Attorney Kamala Harris of quashing the case because his attacker was a political friend who now heads the powerful Alice B. Toklas LGBT Democratic Club.
The suspect, Lawrence Turman, 42, was arrested the night of the attack after several witnesses heard victim Philip Horne, 40, screaming and called the police.
Police found Horne with a "bloody nose and blood on the left side of his face," as well as blood in his mouth and on his teeth, according to the police report.
But shortly afterward Turman co-hosted a charity auction with Harris--who knew about the incident, Horne said--and was then elected co-chairman of the Toklas club.
The district attorney's office later declined to prosecute. [...]
Horne eventually filed a civil suit against Turman, who settled out of court without giving a deposition, Horne said.
Harris' spokeswoman Bilen Mesfin denied that her boss had involved herself in dropping the case.
"The head of the domestic violence division was involved in that," Mesfin said. "Based on the information I have so far, this was a case that could not be prosecuted on the evidence."
The incident occurred on January 1, 2006 at the home the two men had shared for six months at 377 Hermann Street near Duboce Park. The two had been arguing and were about to break up. Horne was picking up some items from the house when Turman arrived and the two argued, he said. [...]
"The next thing I know, his hands are around my neck and he was strangling me in the hallway," said Horne. "Then all of a sudden he starts punching me in the face . . . there was blood all over the hallway."
Turman apologized, then became angry again when Horne tried to call a friend to take him to the hospital. [...]
Turman grabbed the cell phone, and Horne ran toward the front door to escape. Turman tackled him just as he reached the door. [...]
At least two neighbors heard his screams, which were recorded in the background during one of their 911 calls.
Police arrived and interviewed the two men, then arrested Turman for domestic battery. He was bailed out a few hours later. [...]
"Turman told me he had a conversation with you about the decision not to prosecute," Horne wrote in a letter to Harris. "You responded that you did not want to see Turman prosecuted because he is a friend of your but that [you] did not speak directly to the charging District Attorney about the decision." [...]
The only communication Horne ever had from prosecutors about the decision was a short note saying they did not have to explain it, Horne said.

Tuesday, December 11, 2007


WPost More Pro-Gay Than HRC
Over Huckabee AIDS Quarantine View

An editorial in today's Washington Post castigating GOP presidential hopeful Mike Huckabee for his outrageous endorsement of quarantining people with AIDS and lack of tolerance for gays is miles ahead of what the Human Rights Campaign said today in a letter to Huckabee.
The "HIV Clueless" editorial is notable not just because it takes Huckabee to task for his dangerous views, but also for using the words homosexual, gay, and even lesbian, and not in a direct quote from the candidate:
"Actually, in 1992, the year after basketball star Magic Johnson made the dramatic announcement that he was HIV-positive, it was already widely understood -- and widely publicized -- that HIV could not be spread by casual contact or even through close physical contact short of unprotected homosexual or heterosexual sex. [...]
"Nor can his view on AIDS be separated from Mr. Huckabee's animus toward homosexuality, which at the time he called "an aberrant, unnatural and sinful lifestyle." [...]
"But in refusing to "recant," as he put it to Fox News, his 1992 views on AIDS and on homosexuality as a "lifestyle," he fails to lay to rest legitimate doubts about his objectivity and fairmindedness when it comes to the rights and interests of gays and lesbians, and the public health concerns of everyone."
On the HRC front, the nation's largest gay advocacy organization also expresses criticism and strong concern over Huckabee's views, but the group is more upset over his AIDS quarantine remarks and doesn't hold him accountable in anyway for his anti-gay thinking.
HRC's release, asking the former GOP Arkansas governor to meet with them, the AIDS Institute and Ryan White's mom Jeanne, only uses the word homosexuality in a quote from him:
As reported by the Associated Press, "Huckabee once advocated isolating AIDS patients from the general public, opposed increased federal funding in the search for a cure and said homosexuality could ‘pose a dangerous public health risk.’"
Hmmm, the Washington Post is practically falling over itself to use the "h" and "g" words and hold Huckabee to account for his AIDS _and_ gay views, while the leaders at HRC are much more interested in invoking a brave heterosexual kid with AIDS, an "innocent victim" who doesn't raise any troubling icky issues like male-on-male anal transmission of HIV. HRC never says the word gay in their statement!
As if to further show how far it will go to avoid including gay males with AIDS, the HRC letter to Huckabee says this:
Governor Huckabee, if you need a reminder of how calls for "isolation" can shatter a Mother’s heart, you only need to turn to Jeanne White-Ginder.
I have tons of respect for Mrs. White-Ginder and see her as a true heroine in the AIDS battle, but her shattered heart in reaction to the call for isolating AIDS patients should not force HRC to ignore the broken hearts of all people with AIDS, including gays with the disease.
How can HRC go out of its way to omit the concerns and voices of gays with AIDS in this debate? Maybe the HRC leaders have forgotten that gay men are the largest category of people living with HIV/AIDS in America. Whatever the reason for the omissions, HRC continues on its well-worn path of spinelessness.
The Washington Post editorial today, coupled with the New York Times editorial on Monday about the defeat of the hate crimes attachment, are prime evidence of how the mainstream media is better right now at standing up for gays, and in the case of the Post, being more inclusive of gays than the Democratic Party hacks at HRC.